Essential: Generational dynamics in Spain: Memory transmission of a turbulent past

Generational dynamics in Spain: Memory transmission of a turbulent past


Paloma Aguilar, Clara Ramírez-BaratFirst Published October 18, 2016 Research Article

Download PDF Article information


Abstract


Despite the crucial transformations that Spain has experienced since Franco’s death, and in contrast with other countries that have democratized in recent decades, considerable reluctance remains toward implementing transitional justice measures. On the contrary, there is a tendency to hold on to a framework that combines the Amnesty Law of 1977 with partial reparations as the best guarantors of democratic stability. According to extant literature, generational change has played a fundamental role in the direction taken by recent initiatives dealing with the memory of Francoist repression, particularly since 2000. A small but very active part of the “grandchildren’s generation” has driven various initiatives that have influenced political and judicial agendas. We provide empirical evidence showing that while, in general terms, it would be true to say that third and fourth generations have been more supportive of the implementation of bolder memory policies, their contribution must nevertheless be subjected to careful nuancing.
Keywords collective memory, exhumations, Francoism, generations, Spanish Civil War, transitional justice

References
Abad, X (2014) La huella de los abuelos [The Traces of Our Grandparents]. Film. Google Scholar
Adonis, CK (2015) Generational forgiveness and historical injustices: perspectives of descendants of victims of apartheid-era gross human rights violations. Journal of Psychology in Africa 25(1): 6–14. Google Scholar
Aguilar, P (2008a) Políticas de la memoria y memorias de la política. Madrid: Alianza Editorial. Google Scholar
Aguilar, P (2008b) Transitional or post-transitional justice? Recent developments in the Spanish case. South European Society & Politics 13(4): 417–433. Google Scholar, Crossref
Aguilar, P (2016) Mass graves’ exhumations during the Spanish transition: memory initiatives in a context of fear and silence. In: International congress Spain’s Civil War 80 years later: The wound that will not heal?Canterbury Christ Church University, Canterbury, 18–19 July 2016. Google Scholar
Aguilar, P, Ramírez-Barat, C (2014) Amnesty and reparations without truth or justice in Spain. In: Wouters, N (ed.) Transitional Justice and Memory in Europe (1945–2013). Cambridge: Intersentia, pp. 199–258. Google Scholar
Aguilar, P, Ferrándiz, F (2016) Memory, media and spectacle: Interviú ’s portrayal of Civil War exhumations in the early years of Spanish democracy. Journal of Spanish Cultural Studies 17(1): 1–25. Google Scholar, Crossref
Aguilar, P, Balcells, L, Cebolla, H (2011) Determinants of attitudes towards transitional justice: an empirical analysis of the Spanish case. Comparative Political Studies 44(10): 1397–1430. Google Scholar, Link
Armengou, M, Belis, R (2004) Las fosas del silencio. Barcelona: Plaza & Janés. Google Scholar
Assmann, A (2006) “Limits of understanding: generational identities in recent Germany memory literature. In: Cohen-Pfister, L, Wienroeder-Skinner, D (eds) Victims and Perpetrators: 1933–1945: (Re)Presenting the Past in Post-Unification Culture. New York: Walter de Gruyter, pp. 29–48. Google Scholar, Crossref
Baer, A, Sznaider, N (2015) Ghosts of the holocaust in Franco’s mass graves: cosmopolitan memories and the politics of “never again.” Memory Studies 8(3): 1–17. Google Scholar, Link
Balcells, L (2012) The consequences of victimization on political identities: evidence from Spain. Politics & Society 40(3): 311–347. Google Scholar, Link
Barkan, E (2000) The Guilt of Nations: Restitution and Negotiating Historical Injustices. New York: W. W. Norton. Google Scholar
Bullón, De Mendoza, De Diego, A (2000) Historias orales de la guerra civil. Barcelona: Ariel. Google Scholar
Carmil, D, Breznitz, S (1990) Personal trauma and world view—are extremely stressful experiences related to political attitudes, religious beliefs, and future orientation? Journal of Traumatic Stress 4: 393–405. Google Scholar, Crossref
Carrillo, S (2004) Prologue in Armengou M and R Belis, Las fosas del silencio. Barcelona: Plaza & Janés. Google Scholar
Casanova, J, Cenarro, A (2014) Pagar las culpas. La represión política en Aragón (1936–1945). Barcelona: Crítica. Google Scholar
Cohen-Pfister, L, Wienroeder-Skinner, D (2006) Victims and Perpetrators: 1933–1945: (Re)Presenting the Past in Post-Unification Culture. New York: Walter de Gruyter, pp. 29–48. Google Scholar, Crossref
Collins, C (2010) Post-transitional justice: Human rights trials in Chile and El Salvador. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press. Google Scholar
Corning, A, Schuman, H (2015) Generations and Collective Memory. Chicago, IL; London: University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar, Crossref
Danieli, Y (ed.) (1998) International Handbook of Multigenerational Legacies of Trauma. New York: Springer. Google Scholar, Crossref
Davis, M (2005) Is Spain recovering its memory? Breaking the Pacto del Olvido. Human Rights Quarterly 27(3): 858–888. Google Scholar, Crossref
De Grom, B (2011) Second and third-generation trauma representation: a comparison of Thane Rosenbaum’s Second Hand Smoke and Nicole Krauss’s Great House. Master’s Thesis, Universiteit Gent, Ghent. Google Scholar
Encarnación, O (2014) Democracy without Justice in Spain: The Politics of Forgetting. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press. Google Scholar, Crossref
Escudero, R (2014) Road to impunity: the absence of transitional justice programs in Spain. Human Rights Quarterly 36(1): 123–146. Google Scholar, Crossref
Faúndez, X, Cornejo, M (2010) Aproximaciones al estudio de la Transmisión Transgeneracional del Trauma Social. Revista de Psicología 19(2): 31–54. Google Scholar
Ferrándiz, F (2010) De las fosas comunes a los derechos humanos: el descubrimiento de las desapariciones forzadas en la España contemporánea. Revista de Antropología Social 19: 161–189. Google Scholar
Fromm, MG (2012) Lost in Transmission: Studies of Trauma across Generations. London: Karnac. Google Scholar
Garriga, C (2012) La transmisión intergeneracional del trauma. Caso María. CEIR 6(3): 602–619. Google Scholar
Golob, SR (2008) Volver: the return of/to transitional justice politics in Spain. Journal of Spanish Cultural Studies 9(2): 127–141. Google Scholar, Crossref
Gómez López-Quiñones, A (2012) A secret agreement: the historical memory debate and the limits of recognition. Hispanic Issues on Line 11: 87–116. Google Scholar
Guzmán, P (1997) La memoria obstinada [The stubborn memory]. Film. Google Scholar
Hirsch, M (2008) The generation of postmemory. Poetics Today 29(1): 103–128. Google Scholar, Crossref
Jara, D (2013) The aftermath of political violence: the opposition’s second generation in the post-coup Chile and its familial memory. PhD Thesis, Sociology, Goldsmiths, University of London, London. Google Scholar
Jelin, E (2007) Public memorialization in perspective: truth, justice and memory of past repression in the Southern Cone of South America. International Journal of Transitional Justice 1(1): 138–156. Google Scholar, Crossref
Jelin, E, Kaufman, SG (eds) (2006) Subjetividad y Figuras de la Memoria. Buenos Aires: Siglo XXI Editora Iberoamericana. Google Scholar
Jennings, MK, Stoker, K, Bowers, K (2009) Politics across generations: family transmission re-examined. Journal of Politics 71: 782–799. Google Scholar, Crossref
Jerez-Farrán, C, Amago, S (eds) (2010) Unearthing Franco’s Legacy: Mass Graves and the Recovery of Historical Memory. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame. Google Scholar
Juliá, S (2004) Historias de las dos Españas. Madrid: Taurus. Google Scholar
Kahane-Nissenbaum, MC (2011) Exploring intergenerational transmission of trauma in third generation Holocaust survivors. Doctoral Dissertation, Social Work (Paper 16), University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA. Google Scholar
Kaiser, S (2005) Postmemories of Terror: A New Generation Copes with the Legacy of the “Dirty War.” New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Google Scholar, Crossref
Kaplan, T (2004) Taking Back the Streets: Women, Youth, and Direct Democracy. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Google Scholar
Kornetis, K (2014) “Is there a future in this past? Analyzing 15M’s intricate relation to the Transición. Journal of Spanish Cultural Studies 15(1–2): 83–98. Google Scholar, Crossref
Lessa, F, Levey, C (2015) From blanket impunity to judicial opening(s) H.I.J.O.S. and memory making in postdictatorship Argentina (2005–2012). Latin American Perspectives 42(3): 207–225. Google Scholar, Link
Mannheim, K (1952) Essays in the Sociology of Knowledge. London: Routledge. Google Scholar
Martín, I (2004) Significados y orígenes del interés por la política en dos nuevas democracias: España y Grecia. Madrid: CEACS. Google Scholar
Martín, S (2009) Memoria(s) en disputa. Transmisión de memoria en el contexto posdictatorial argentino y chileno.Los casos de HIJOS La Plata y la AFDD Paine (1973–2008). Revista Virtual Historia y Patrimonio 2, Universidad Diego Portales. Google Scholar
Miñarro, A, Morandi, T (2009) Trauma psíquico y transmisión intergeneracional. Efectos psíquicos de la guerra del 36, la posguerra, la dictadura y la transición en los ciudadanos de Cataluña. In: Vinyes, R (ed.) El Estado y la memoria. Gobiernos y ciudadanos frente a los traumas de la historia. Barcelona: RBA, pp. 441–463. Google Scholar
Miñarro, A, Morandi, T (2012) Trauma psíquico y transmission: Represión, silencio, memoria y salud mental. Barcelona: Fundació Congrés Català de Salut Mental. Google Scholar
Ortega Díaz-Ambrona, JA (2015) Memorial de transiciones (1939–1978). La generación de 1978. Barcelona: Galaxia Gutenberg. Google Scholar
Pesquera, P (2012) The Intergenerational Transmission of Party Preferences within the Family. Madrid: CEACS. Google Scholar
Renshaw, L (2011) Exhuming Loss: Memory, Materiality and Mass Graves of the Spanish Civil War. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press. Google Scholar
Ros, A (2012) The Post-Dictatorship Generation in Argentina, Chile, and Uruguay: Collective Memory and Cultural Production. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Google Scholar, Crossref
Scharf, M (2007) Long-term effects of trauma: psychosocial functioning of the second and third generation of holocaust survivors. Development and Psychopathology 19: 603–622. Google Scholar, Crossref, Medline
Schuman, H, Corning, A (2012) Generational memory and the critical period: evidence for national and world events. Public Opinion Quarterly 76(1): 1–31. Google Scholar, Crossref
Schuman, H, Scott, J (1989) Generations and collective memories. American Sociological Review 54(3): 359–381. Google Scholar, Crossref
Serrano, JE (2016) La exhumación de 1979 en Murcia. Acción colectiva de familiares de fusilados republicanos durante la transición. Ayer 103(3): 147–177. Google Scholar
Silva, E, Macías, A (2003) Las fosas de Franco. Madrid: Temas de Hoy. Google Scholar
Stan, L (2009) Transitional Justice in Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union: Reckoning with the Communist Past. New York: Routledge. Google Scholar
Styskal, RA, Sullivan, HJ (1975) Intergenerational continuity and congruence on political values. Political Research Quarterly 28: 516–527. Google Scholar, Link
Tamarit, JC (2013) Historical Memory and Criminal Justice in Spain: A Case of Late Transitional Justice. Cambridge: Intersentia. Google Scholar
Valverde, C (2014) Desenterrar las palabras. Transmisión generacional del trauma de la violencia política del siglo XX en el Estado español. Barcelona: Icaria. Google Scholar
Valverde, C, Martín-Cabrera, L (2015) The silence of the grandchildren of the Civil War: transgenerational trauma in Spain. In: O’Loughlin, M, Barbre, C (eds) The Ethics of Remembering and the Consequences of Forgetting. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 203–227. Google Scholar
Wood, E (2008) The social processes of civil war: the wartime transformation of social networks. Annual Review of Political Science 11: 539–561. Google Scholar, Crossref